Clouds, part I: When they interfere with the landscape in photography

Published by

on

I’ve been wanting to write about ‘clouds’ for some time. Though we don’t often see many clouds around here, they make their occasional appearance, driving photographers into a frenzy of landscape photography.

Whenever clouds grace the sky, local photography groups and friends’ social media feeds overflow with posts capturing the moment. Yet, I often find myself pondering: when do clouds enhance the narrative of a photo?

More often than not, clouds don’t help

While clouds can add a welcomed dimension to a landscape, at times, they serve only to confuse or distract. Take, for example, the photograph below, taken on 03/23/2024, at Rush Ranch in Fairfield. What is this photo about? Is it about the green, rolling hills, or the messy sky?

On the same day, the captivating play of light on the mountains caught my eye and led me to capture the moment. However, upon returning home, I realized that the clouds, though foreboding, clashed with and detracted from the focal point I intended to showcase.

One strategy for dealing with strange-strange-shapped clouds that cause visual confusion rather than enhance the landscape is to shift the focus of the photograph to emphasize the cloud formations. The photo below is a crop of an image taken a few minutes after the image above, when the cloud was more dense. At least in this case, the viewer knows what he is looking at. Converted to black and white, the shape of the cloud is emphasized.

When I encounter an intriguing cloud formation that doesn’t harmonize with the scene but rather competes with it, I opt to center the photograph around the cloud itself. In the example below, the angelic silhouette of the cloud inspired me to capture the moment. Including the landscape would have only created confusion. This photograph was initially featured in my blog post ‘You Look Like an Angel: A Cloud Formation in the Sky Above.’”

Omnious skies

An ominous sky can dramatically alter the mood and atmosphere of a landscape, but it also presents challenges for photographers. While such skies can add a sense of drama and intrigue, they often overshadow or obscure the intended subject of the photograph. The dark and brooding clouds, coupled with dim lighting, can make it difficult to highlight key elements in the scene, leading to a loss of clarity and focus. As a result, photographers must carefully consider how to navigate and work with these atmospheric conditions to ensure that the subject remains prominent and discernible amidst the ominous backdrop.

Sometimes, as in the case below, a photograph taken on 03/23/2024 at Grizzly Island, going back to the scene for another shot might be the best solution. I wanted to emphasize the windmills of the Central Valley, but no matter how much I spin it, the ominous sky dominates, and the interface of whites and blacks created by the clouds has resulted in a busy frame.

Somewhere over the rainbow

My photo buddy and I were excited to encounter this rainbow scene on a county road, but the clouds were there to “steal the thunder”.

A different approach using a long lens, yielded better results when the clouds were excluded.

Conclusion:

Distracting cloud formations, ominous skies and clouds surrounding a rainbow sometimes ruin landscape photography. It behoves the photographer to look for angles, lenses and crops that will simplify the scene and guide the viewers’ eye. If a compromise cannot be found, coming back to the scene on another day is better than showing a frame that is both busy and confusing.

In “Clouds, part II”, I will discuss and show examples of clouds that either complement or at least are neutral in the landscape. Stay tuned!

—————————————–———————————————

Wall Art Botanical Images

Wall Art Photography projects

Wall Art Landscapes

—————————————–———————————————

13 responses to “Clouds, part I: When they interfere with the landscape in photography”

  1. nancyb422 Avatar

    Very interesting! I understand what you’re saying and will go back to some landscape photos to see if that is the issue in them.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      It’s a good exercise for sure.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Anne Sandler Avatar

    Great topic and interesting Alessandra. Would you rather have no clouds? Hopefully you’ll talk about a pure blue sky and how to handle it in part 2! I like good clouds that compliment, but I’ve never thought of clouds taking away from the focal point of a composition. Looking forward to part 2!

    Like

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      I like it when the clouds complement, rather than distract from, the landscape. I hope I can do a good job in part 2!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Steve Schwartzman Avatar

    I differ with you about the second picture. While I often take pictures of clouds in their own right (as coincidentally in my post this morning), sometimes I like to anchor cloudscapes to the earth by including a little fringe of land at the bottom, as in your second shot, where the undulating hills even add their own contours to those of the clouds.

    In your next-to-the-last view, the upper clouds don’t bother me, though I understand why you might not want to include them if your purpose is to emphasize the rainbow. Along those lines, another possibility is to crop off the top 2/3 of that photograph and leave a panoramic view of the rainbow stretching over the land.

    Like

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      Thanks for your input. I may not have done the greatest job showing how clouds don’t work with the landscape because often when that’s a serious case I tend not to shoot. My point is that sometimes clouds make it a whole lot worse. But I can see that leaving some of the clouds in the last picture might work as well. That’s the advantage of getting feedback, people often see things I don’t see.

      Like

      1. Steve Schwartzman Avatar

        Not only do different people see a given thing differently, the same person may see something differently at different times. You may have had the experience I’ve often enough had of looking back at a picture of mine, being unhappy with the way I processed it (for example too dark or overly saturated), and reprocessing it to make it better—at least according to my sensibilities of the moment. Fortunately modern software makes it pretty easy to have second thoughts and act on them.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. shoreacres Avatar

    I smiled at your remark that you don’t often see clouds. When I moved to the Bay Area, it began to bother me that every day was bright, sunny, and blue; I longed to see a cloud of any sort, but I especially missed the towering cumulus. There are plenty of those here.

    I actually prefer the photo that includes the clouds with the rainbow. The light playing on the clouds almost always accompanies a rainbow; it’s part of what makes them exciting. The cropped photo is, in its way, more aesthetically pleasing, but not so dramatic.

    I rather like the second photo, too. Rather than being messy, I see the sky as a chaotic complement to the smooth roll of the hills. It’s one of those photos that’s less an either/or than a both/and. The hills and clouds together are wonderful.

    Like

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      It’s already that time of the year when it’s a blue sky every day. This is going to be the case till mid to late October. In the case of the second photo, I have a similar one i will show on another chapter, where the clouds really complement the landscape. I have a comparison you don’t yet have. I can see how leaving some of the clouds as Steve suggested might help in the case of the rainbow picture. I will try that.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. howg2211 Avatar
    howg2211

    interesting. I never really thought of clouds as distracting and, while I personally don’t find them distracting in all the photos you’ve used, I think the point is really brought home in the final rainbow shot. In that one I completely ageee that the one without the clouds draws me in and gets my attention on the rainbow to a far better degree. So point well taken.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      I didn’t do the greatest job with my examples but I don’t have many because I’m aware and weary of clouds that distract. Unfortunately it would not be nice to use the photos from others that have inspired this post. I behoove each photographer to look into their own portfolio look of those.

      Like

  6. gederedita Avatar

    nice view

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      Thank you.

      Like

Leave a reply to howg2211 Cancel reply

Discover more from It is all about the light

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading