What about black and white? Drama. Chapter 4.

Published by

on

In chapter 1, chapter 2 and Chapter 3 of this series of posts I showed photographs that do not lend themselves well to black and white conversion because they rely on colors and saturation for the separation of the main elements in the composition. In chapter 4, I presented a series of photos that are characterized by high contrast between shadow and light, and asked my followers to verbalize other characteristics of those photos that helped to make them stand out in black and white. Summarizing the answers, below are some additional characteristics displayed by at least one of those photos linked here:

  1. Color does not play an important role in the composition;
  2. Geometrical lines, angles;
  3. Repetitive patterns;
  4. Simplicity;
  5. Texture.

To the list above, I will add one that is a little more difficult to define or explain: drama.

If you are a woman, you probably have heard numerous times that you were making drama or being dramatic by a significant man in your life. Maybe you felt like you had to defend yourself from the accusation, but you were not able to.

Because drama is a somewhat personal experience.

When I saw the image below, I immediately recognized the implied drama in it. After conversion to bring it out, the FEATURED IMAGE (f/20, 1.3 s, ISO 160), in my opinion, looks stronger in its black and white version. If you are curious about the story behind this image, I wrote a post about it last year.

I think the impact of the images in my collection “Light Matters” mostly rely on drama. But I could be wrong because drama, after all, is a very personal experience.

Breaking rules that don’t exist

In this series of posts, I have been attempting to raise awareness about the potential enhancement of certain compositions when converted to black and white. Throughout this process, various individuals have visited and commented, expressing their belief that this notion is untrue. According to them, all images can be effectively transformed into monochrome, and some people have even preferred the color versions of images that I initially favored in black and white.

I would like to take a moment to remind everyone that the information I am sharing here serves as mere pointers or tips, intended to assist you in saving time and approaching your photography with a deliberate mindset when working without color. Photography does not adhere to rigid rules, and I do not consider myself an expert in black and white photography. I simply wish to share my limited experience, hoping that these posts will be of assistance to those who are interested in black and white photography but unsure of where to begin.

______________________________

Wall Art Botanical Images

Wall Art Photography projects

Wall Art landscapes and miscellaneous

________________________________

17 responses to “What about black and white? Drama. Chapter 4.”

  1. howg2211 Avatar
    howg2211

    It’s a beautiful image. In addition to the black and white it’s also the ‘drama’ you infused with excellent post-processing skills, particularly in the sky and cliffs. In this instance I think such dramatic enhancement is amplified by black and white more so than color would. It’s the light.

    Like

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      That’s right, I wouldn’t be able to do it in color. It’s possible though that other people would. Thanks for the kind comments.

      Like

  2. Dave Baldwin Avatar

    Sorry you’re having to suffer critics. They seem to be everywhere and for all kinds of art.

    Like

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      LOL isn’t it?

      Like

  3. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

    Wow the B&W version is striking (the photo is color is awesome too)!
    I’ve experimented with B&W photography with my iPhone camera and this posts helps me understand why some photos do not work in B&W (even when I thought they would be brilliant) and why some do! I am behind in reading posts so I might learn more as I go backyard in reading this series of posts.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      With an iPhone you may want to narrow down your field of vision and shoot for simpler compositions that highlight shadow and light. People do awesome stuff w these iPhone cameras.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. tierneycreates: a fusion of textiles and smiles Avatar

        Thanks so much for that tip 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

  4. Steve Schwartzman Avatar

    The black and white version comes across to me as stormier, and therefore offers more drama—to use the word you favor. You’ve come up with a clever aphorism in “Breaking rules that don’t exist.” It would have made a good title for a work in the tradition called theater of the absurd. You do a service in reminding people that “Photography does not adhere to rigid rules.”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      It really doesn’t have rigid rules, but there are guidelines which, when followed, often result in more pleasing images.

      Like

  5. shoreacres Avatar

    In this instance, I much prefer the black and white image. My inexperienced eye tells me there was much more involved in the development of the image than simply changing from color to black and white. The pristine buildings and lighthouse, the increase in darkness over the water, the lighting in the clouds and on the waves are what create the sense of drama; without them, it seems the image might have been as ‘non-dramatic’ in B&W as in color.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      Yes your “ inexperienced” eyes don’t lack discernment 😉. My next series of about black and white posts will be about the post-processing.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. WritingfromtheheartwithBrian Avatar

    Beautiful shot (whether in color or B/W). I love your line too “breaking rules that don’t exist.” I think that applies to life too!!!!😎😎😎

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      Photographers love rules that only apply to others. 😎😅

      Liked by 1 person

  7. Steve Gingold Avatar

    Considering the “nature” of my choices in subjects, most do rely on color to give them their fullest meaning. Basically that meaning is that Nature is beautiful and should be protected and revered rather than seen as just an amusement for bored people. Some does work well in B&W. For landscape imagery it is quite different and, of course as you have shown many times, flowers can work exceedingly well in monochrome also.
    The image you’ve highlighted does have a dramatic quality that you enhanced in your processing and conversion. I think that it would be possible to create something along those same lines in color but of course that would have a much different appearance and give possibly a different interpretation opportunity for a viewer. Your work on this file is very good and the image pleasing to view.

    On a side note, I’ve never described a woman as being “dramatic” and especially not my wife. Overly sensitive, maybe. 🙂 I tend to be the more emotional of the two of us…and the more sensitive.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      The problem with color is that it comes with the expectation of reality. That something is being portrayed as is. It’s very easy to go overboard with a color photo in post processing. But since a black and white world doesn’t exist, there is more freedom in post processing without raising ampm eyebrow. I’ve seen some of your b&w they were very good. A waterfall as I recall.

      Liked by 1 person

  8. Antonio Mozeto Avatar

    It really is very difficult if not impossible to say that there are rules for converting a photo in color (because ALL are in color when we photograph it in digital cameras) in black and white. I follow your “rule”: when I want DRAMA I look for the best conversion to B&W…
    And, the photos that I keep and improve the colors, I follow my eye, my heart, my stomach, a kind of instinct that tells me that this photo is in color and the discussion is over….

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Alessandra Chaves Avatar

      Obrigada por tirar um minuto do seu tempo para fazer um comentário no meu blog. Tudo de bom 😌 e tenha uma ótima semana.

      Like

Leave a comment

Discover more from It is all about the light

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading