Backstory
I mentioned to some of my photographer peers that I was reading Yan Robert’s “ Mastering composition” to refine my composition skills. I was happy to refer the book and to communicate that I was learning something new. I described his method: take a photograph, then sketch the scene with simplified elements to work on the compositional details. Although we cannot build upon a sketch back to a photograph, I expressed that I wanted to train my eyes to identify the important elements in my compositions before clicking the shutter.
My endeavor did not get a lot of support, interest, or sympathy from my peers. Most pronounced themselves against following any “rules” of composition. In some cases I felt like I’d inadvertently hit a spot, some seemed upset.
Digging into my past memory, often when I mentioned the word “composition” in a positive way on social media, I got a push back from photographers. And that’s what today’s blog post is about.
Why don’t we, photographers, want to do the hard work?
Whereas painters spend a great deal of time learning to compose their canvases, many photographers just want to pick up the camera and go make art. It’s not uncommon among us to be ignorant about composition beyond emphasizing curves, diagonals, and the rule of thirds. This has us making the same photographs over and over again, in different places. And I ask, why are we so resistant to learning to build more complex compositions?
- Creativity vs. Constraints: One of the primary reasons photographers resist learning composition is the fear of being confined or restricted in their creativity. They worry that adhering too closely to established “rules” may stifle their ability to think outside the box and experiment with unconventional compositions. While creativity thrives on freedom, it’s essential to recognize that understanding composition serves as a foundation, providing a structure that can be creatively bent or broken when necessary.
- Personal Style and Expression: Every photographer develops a unique style and vision over time. This individuality is a result of personal experiences, preferences, and artistic goals. Some photographers resist learning composition because they believe it may dilute their distinctive style or lead to images that feel formulaic. However, mastering composition doesn’t mean sacrificing personal expression. Instead, it empowers photographers to communicate their vision more effectively by making informed choices about how to arrange elements within the frame.
- Fear of Conformity: In photography circles, there’s often a fear of conforming to established norms or trends. Some photographers resist learning composition because they want to avoid producing work that feels too similar to what others are creating. While this concern is valid, it’s essential to understand that mastering composition doesn’t equate to copying or imitating others. Instead, it allows photographers to understand why certain compositions work effectively and empowers them to apply this knowledge in their unique way.
- Laziness: These days no one wants to do the hard work. The complexity of composition theory can feel overwhelming. A sense of technical overwhelm can lead some photographers to avoid learning composition altogether, opting instead to rely on instinct or trial and error. However, breaking down these guidelines into digestible concepts and practicing them gradually can help alleviate this barrier.
- Embracing Evolution: Art, including photography, is a constantly evolving field. What may be considered a norm today might be challenged or redefined tomorrow. Some photographers resist learning composition because they believe in embracing the fluidity and evolution of art. While it’s true that artistic norms evolve, understanding the foundational principles of composition provides a timeless framework that can adapt to changing trends and styles.
In conclusion, the resistance that some photographers exhibit towards learning the rules of composition is multifaceted and rooted in legitimate concerns about creativity, individuality, and artistic evolution. However, by viewing composition guidelines as tools rather than constraining rules, embracing education and practice, and finding a balance between theory and intuition, photographers can harness the power of composition to elevate their work and communicate their unique vision effectively.
The FEATURED PHOTOGRAPH
The FEATURED PHOTOGRAPH, repeated below for convenience, is titled “let’s talk about composition“. In my head, I pictured a photographer teasing her peers about composition ;-). I took it at the UC Davis campus near the Veterinary Hospital. In the same area, there are a number of other installations featuring animals. How fitting!
AI-generated critique of my post
I have recently come across new features on WordPress. One is AI’s feedback on one’s post. Below is what AI has to say about the post above (the feature can be found under “post” at the bottom “AI Assistant” :
“The content provides a personal experience related to studying composition and addresses the resistance some photographers have towards learning composition rules. It also presents valid reasons for this resistance and emphasizes the importance of understanding composition as a foundational framework for creative expression. The writing effectively communicates the author’s viewpoint and encourages a balanced approach to composition, acknowledging both creativity and structure.
Actionable feedback:
1. Consider providing specific examples or visual references to illustrate the impact of composition on photography.
2. Include practical tips or exercises for overcoming the barriers to learning composition, enhancing the reader’s experience.
3. Encourage engagement by asking readers about their experiences with composition and inviting them to share their perspectives on the topic.”
______________________________
Wall Art landscapes and miscellaneous
________________________________
It is all about the light 
Leave a comment